Find my latest American Idol article here.
I think Barry Manilow is really a nice guy who cares about these kids and wants them to do well.
I get frustrated every time the contestants get to Hollywood. I just don’t understand the agenda of the show’s producers or the judges.
First of all, I do not understand why the producers decide to spend several minutes of the show rehashing stories about from people that they have already given time to such as that rat-haired blonde Rose who really can sing. Why do we need to spend 3 minutes following her around at the expense of four other contestants in the same line with her that we barely got to even see much less hear from? And, why would they spend extra time on the ones who got kicked off after they have already been sent packing? I want to hear the singers. This is nothing new, but realizing that the top 24 have already been decided before the shows air this week, I will find it unacceptable and unfair if there are any of the top 24 that have not been shown singing by the time that they announce who has made that cut. This has happened in the past, and there is no excuse for it.
Second, it was clear that if you can sing at all, a bit will get you through. That was proved by the idiot, Norman Gentle and Bikini Girl who were not that good at all. Jackie Tone and her Janis Joplin impersonation were painfully bad. They got through to the group sing where they will effectively destroy the dreams of up to a half dozen other young people with their antics and lack of talent.
Third, just for the record, I for one am not sorry that they sent Dennis the Ingrate home.
Fourth, Why do I feel like the judges expect me to think some people are great when they really are not that good just because they, the judges, say so? I use Lil’ who yelled and sang off pitch and Jackie Tone as a couple of examples. This has happened in the past, but I usually do not notice it until they get into the final 24.
And fifth, David Osmond may just win this competition.
Filed under: American Idol, Hot Opinions, Music, Television | Tagged: 2009, Abdul, American Idol, Auditions, Bad, Barry Manilow, Bikini Girl, contestants, country music, Cowell, David Osmond, Dennis, Entertainment, Funny, Group Sing, Hip Hop, Hollywood Week, Humor, Humour, Jackie Tone, Janis Joplin, Judge, Kara, Kara DioGuardi, Lil, Media, Music, New, news, Norman Gentle, Paula, Paula Abdul, Pop Music, predictions, producers, Randy, Randy Jackson, Rap, review, Rock, Rose, Ryan, Ryan Seacrest, Seacrest, Season 8, Simon, Simon Cowell, Talent, Television, Top 24, Tryouts | Leave a Comment »