Find my latest American Idol article here.
We were told at the beginning, after Ryan had wasted four minutes babbling, that there would only be two judges commenting after each performance. I don’t like this idea at all, because it means that Simon will not be heard half the time. Simon correctly identified the girls as the problem (fire one or both, no problem), but they quickly wasted even more time with a three minutes on a Quinten Tarantino montage. Even stranger was the fact that Tarantino was the guest judge. What does he know about it? Of course, the theme was movie themes.
Allison Iraheta, “I Don’t Want to Miss a Thing”- This was not her best by a long shot. It was breathy, and affected, as usual. Mainly, it seemed flat and fairly underwhelming, while at the same time coming across as indulgent and unforgettable. This could be a bad combination with her leading off the show.
Paula and Simon complimented her.
Anoop Desai, “Every Thing I Do, I Do It For You”- He sounded great at the beginning, and carried that through to the first chorus. When he held out the big notes, they still had strong, pure, even tones that sounded just great. It was his best in a couple of weeks.
Randy and Kara loved it also.
Adam Lambert, “Born to be Wild”- Why are we even continuing with this farce of a competition? It was not my favorite vocal by him, but it was still an amazing performance. It always seems like a concert when he’s on stage. I can see why someone would not like it, but it was still incredible. I think he is the best performer that they have ever had on the show. Period.
Paula said he was one of the bravest contestants that they have ever had. Simon liked the vocal but did not like the performance as much.
Matt Giraud, “To Really Love Woman”- I thought this song would be good for him, and it was. It was not as pretty as Brian Adams’ version, but that is not Matt’s style. It got out of pitch one time, but for the most part it was very good.
Randy and Kara did not like it as much as I did. They insightfully pointed out that when you change the melody of a great song, and add runs, they have to be perfect, and they were not.
Danny Gokey, “Endless Love”- I thought this would be a hard song for one person to sing. It got very good at the chorus. It was his best vocal in a couple of weeks. It built, and got prettier as it went along. Very nice.
Simon oddly criticized him for singing it well, and singing it traditionally. Paula loved it.
Kris Allen, “Falling Slowly”- I did not know this song, but it sounded great at the beginning. The harmony was the best that I have heard from the background singers this season. This vocal was simply beautiful. This tone of his voice was amazing, and the emotion was great.
Randy was a complete idiot. He needs to take that tin ear of his back to the place where he got it. Kara rightly loved it.
Lil Rounds, “The Rose”- This is an easy vocal. I know because I can sing it. That is usually how I determine the difficulty of anything on Idol. The beginning seemed disjointed. It was another one of those songs that need tell a story, the way she cut it up was weird. Otherwise it was pitchy and a mess.
Paula was nonsensical. Simon hated the song choice.
It is time for Lil to go.
Filed under: American Idol, Music, Hot Opinions, Television | Tagged: American Idol, Simon, Randy, Paula, Ryan, contestants, Paula Abdul, Music, country music, Funny, Television, news, Humor, Judge, Kara DioGuardi, Humour, New, Abdul, Talent, Pop Music, Rock, Seacrest, Simon Cowell, Cowell, Kara, 2009, Tryouts, Auditions, Rap, Hip Hop, Randy Jackson, Ryan Seacrest, Season 8, Endless Love, Alexis Grace, Anoop Desai, Michael Sarver, Danny Gokey, Jasmine Murray, Matt Giraud, Kris Allen, Adam Lambert, Scott MacIntyre, Jorge Nunez, Lil Rounds, Megan Corkrey, Allison Irahita, Top 7, Top Seven, Tuesday, April 14, April 14th, I Don’t Want to Miss a Thing, Every Thing I Do, Born to be Wild, To Really Love Woman, Falling Slowly, The Rose | 2 Comments »